The 8 software quality metrics that actually matter

Taylor Bruneaux


In software development, quality is everything. But let’s face it – with so many metrics out there, it’s hard to know which ones actually matter. So, we’ve done the heavy lifting for you. Here are the eight software quality metrics that really count. These key indicators will help you streamline your processes, boost efficiency, and keep your projects aligned with your business goals.

Here are eight of the critical metrics to truly understand your software quality

1. Code quality

Code quality measures the maintainability, readability, and efficiency of your codebase. High-quality code is easy to understand, modify, and extend, reducing the likelihood of bugs and errors. Ensuring code quality is crucial for maintaining a secure, robust, scalable software product.

Maintaining high code quality ensures that your software is robust and scalable. It also facilitates easier debugging and future enhancements, leading to lower long-term costs and higher satisfaction among the entire team, including software developers and stakeholders.

How to measure code quality

Use static code analysis tools likeSonarQube to identify code smells, duplications, and complexity issues in your codebase. Regularcode reviews also help maintain high standards. Key aspects to consider includecode complexity metrics,lines of code added, and code churn rates. However, it’s crucial to understand that these metrics are basic and only provide a rudimentary understanding of code quality. They are meaningful only when combined with other quantitative and qualitative metrics.

2. Test coverage

Test coverage refers to the percentage of your code tested by automated tests. Higher test coverage indicates that more parts of your code are validated against potential issues, ensuring the functionality and security of your software product.

High test coverage reduces the risk of undetected bugs and ensures your software behaves as expected. It also provides confidence when making changes or adding new features, ultimately contributing to high-quality software.

How to measure test coverage

Tools like Jest, JUnit, or pytest can measure test coverage. Aim for a high percentage, but remember that quality is more important than quantity. Consider unit and manual tests during your testing cycle to cover a comprehensive range of software functions.

3. Defect density

Defect density measures the number of defects (bugs) found in a specific amount of code (usually per thousand lines of code). This metric is essential in identifying the quality of software products at different stages of the software development life cycle.

Tracking defect density helps identify problematic areas in your codebase. Lower defect density indicates higher code quality and more reliable software, leading to fewer quality issues and repair times.

How to measure defect density

Calculate defect density by dividing the total number of defects by the size of the codebase in thousands of lines of code (KLOC). Use project management tools to log and analyze defects over a specific period.

4. Mean time to recovery (MTTR)

MTTR is the average time it takes to restore a system to full functionality after a failure. This metric highlights the efficiency of your team’s response to incidents and the robustness of your software solution.

A lower MTTR indicates a resilient system capable of quickly recovering from issues, minimizing downtime and user impact. This metric is crucial for maintaining high customer satisfaction and meeting customer expectations. Mean time to recovery is a DORA metric that can provide insight into your software delivery processes.

How to measure MTTR

Track the time from issue detection to resolution using monitoring tools and incident management systems likePagerDuty orOpsgenie. These tools ensure continuous monitoring and quick response times. Additionally, a dashboard likeDX can synthesize data across platforms to help you understand your MTTR.

5. Lead time for changes

Lead time for changes is another DORA metric that measures the time it takes from committing a code change to deploying it into production. This metric reflects the efficiency of your software development process and the effectiveness of your continuous integration (CI) practices.

Shorter lead times indicate an efficient development process, allowing you to respond quickly to market changes and user feedback. Quick iterations are significant in agile development environments.

How to measure lead time for changes

Use continuous integration/continuous deployment (CI/CD) pipelines to track the time from commit to deployment. Tools like Jenkins, CircleCI, and GitHub Actions can help automate and monitor this process, ensuring an agile metric for your development cycles.

6. Customer-reported bugs

The customer-reported bugs metric counts how many problems users find after releasing the software. This metric reflects how well the software works for users and indicates the success of your testing.

A lower number of customer-reported bugs indicates that your internal testing processes are effective and your software meets user expectations. This outcome leads to higher customer satisfaction and reduces the costs associated with fixing bugs in production.

How to measure bugs

Use issue tracking systems like Jira, Trello, or GitHub Issues to log and monitor customer-reported bugs. Regularly review and analyze these reports to identify patterns and areas for improvement. Analyzing customer satisfaction through surveys can also provide valuable insights.

7. Release frequency

Release frequency measures how often your team releases new software versions to users. Frequent releases demonstrate a responsive and agile development process, ensuring prompt delivery of new features and bug fixes.

Frequent releases demonstrate an ability to respond quickly to user needs and market changes. This agility is crucial for maintaining a competitive edge and delivering exceptional user experience.

How to measure release frequency

Track the number of releases over a specific period, such as monthly or quarterly. Use CI/CD tools to automate the release process and ensure consistency. Monitoring the time between failures and the stability of each release can provide additional insights into your process.

8. User satisfaction

User satisfaction measures how happy and satisfied users are with your software. High user satisfaction indicates that your software meets user requirements and expectations, leading to increased adoption and retention.

High user satisfaction is essential for the success of your software development project. When users appreciate and value your product, it lays the foundation for long-term success.

How to measure user satisfaction

Collect feedback through surveys, net promoter scores (NPS), or user reviews. Tools like SurveyMonkey, Typeform, and Google Forms can help gather and analyze user feedback. Consider factors such as response time and app performance efficiency to gauge overall satisfaction.

Measuring and understanding developer experience

While individual metrics are crucial for gauging specific aspects of software quality, understanding your overall developer experience (DevEx) provides a more comprehensive picture. Developer experience encompasses quantitative and qualitative measures, offering insights into how your development team feels and performs.

A holistic approach to measuring DevEx can uncover underlying issues that single metrics might miss. It helps identify areas for improvement in team satisfaction, productivity, and overall morale. This comprehensive view ensures that the development environment is conducive to producing high-quality software.

How to measure developer experience

Combine quantitative data (such as the above metrics) with qualitative feedback gathered through surveys, one-on-one interviews, and team meetings. This mixed-method approach ensures a well-rounded understanding of your team’s experience and identifies actionable insights for continuous improvement.

By prioritizing a comprehensive view of developer experience, organizations foster a more supportive and productive environment, ultimately leading to higher software quality, developer productivity, and team satisfaction. This commitment to software quality through a balanced scorecard approach ensures consideration of all relevant metrics, providing a complete picture of the health and performance of your software projects.

How DX can give you insight into software quality through developer experience metrics

DX is a developer intelligence platform combining qualitative and quantitative metrics to view your software development processes comprehensively. Unlike traditional tools focusing solely on output metrics, DX’s unique approach includes the DevEx 360 survey tool, which quantifies internal developer experience, and the Data Cloud, which unifies diverse metrics from various sources. This combination allows teams to measure and understand not only the productivity of their developers but also their overall satisfaction, engagement, and experience.

By leveraging DX, organizations can gain deeper insights into critical aspects of software quality. The platform’s ability to integrate real-time feedback and comprehensive data analysis helps identify potential issues early in the development cycle. This proactive approach ensures that software projects are aligned with user requirements and business goals, leading to higher-quality software products and improved customer satisfaction. Through its holistic perspective, DX enables teams to make data-driven decisions that enhance the development environment, streamline processes, and, ultimately, deliver remarkable software solutions.

June 20, 2024

Get started

Want to explore more?

See the DX platform in action.

Get a demo